Can Argentina Survive Without Messi in Copa América?

We’ve grown accustomed to Lionel Messi carrying Argentina — his left foot, his vision, his aura. For nearly two decades, he’s been the answer to almost every question the Albiceleste faced. But what happens when he isn’t on the pitch?

At 37, even Messi needs rest. Lionel Scaloni knows this. Managing a legend means knowing when to unleash him — and when to protect him. But therein lies the dilemma: when a team builds around a singular genius, removing that piece often makes the whole structure wobble.

The good news? Argentina aren’t hollow without him. Far from it. Emiliano Martínez remains a rock in goal — vocal, commanding, and always clutch. Julián Álvarez brings tireless movement and sharp instincts up front. Rodrigo De Paul continues to be the heartbeat of midfield, while Enzo Fernández offers poise and passing range beyond his years. This team just won back-to-back Copa Américas — and they did it in 2024 with Messi playing a more measured, strategic role.

The challenge, however, is chemistry. When Messi plays, everything flows through him — sometimes by design, sometimes by deference. Without him, Argentina must rediscover a collective rhythm. Who takes responsibility in the final third? Who dictates tempo? Who dares to take risks?

These are the growing pains of evolution. But they’re necessary. Because one day — maybe not this tournament, but soon — Messi won’t be there at all. And if Argentina want to keep competing at the highest level, they must learn to shine without his shadow.

So if Messi sits out the group stage, it’s not the end of the world. It’s a test. One that could reveal just how much Argentina have grown — and whether they’re ready to be more than just a one-man masterpiece.

It’s a risk. But maybe, just maybe, it’s the beginning of something even bigger.